With a brand new forged and creator carrying on the Sherlock Holmes torch on the community, Lucy Liu is addressing the possibilities of an Elementary revival on CBS. The present, which ran from 2012-19, served as a modern-day replace on Arthur Conan Doyle’s iconic non-public detective, seeing him having to dwell with Dr. Joan Watson as she works as his sober companion following a keep in rehab, with Watson reluctantly becoming a member of him on his investigations. Jonny Lee Miller and Liu led the Elementary forged as Sherlock and Watson, with the present praised all through its run for its writing, character improvement and performances.
Now, throughout a latest interview with ScreenRant for her action-comedy Outdated Man, Liu was requested about the opportunity of an Elementary revival, notably after CBS not too long ago launched its religious sequel, Watson. The 2-time Emmy nominee started by admitting she by no means actually thinks about the opportunity of a follow-up to the present, although did specific her gratitude for the continued love of hers and curiosity about future diversifications of Doyle’s works. Take a look at what Liu shared under:
I do not give it some thought, as a result of it seems like we actually had closure on it. Thanks for watching the seven seasons of Elementary. I really feel prefer it was such a blur, as a result of whenever you’re doing tv, you are on a treadmill, and also you simply cannot cease. So, I simply beloved working with Rob Doherty, who created the present and created these very attention-grabbing characters that developed and will develop and alter. I do not know that that might ever occur, however I am glad that persons are nonetheless in a position to have spinoffs on Holmes, as a result of clearly, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle was on to one thing, and the legacy continues.
What This Means For Elementary’s Potential Revival
The Present Has A Few Potential Hurdles To Overcome To Return
Although Liu could really feel that the Elementary collection finale introduced closure to the present, it definitely did not shut the door completely on the opportunity of her Watson and Miller’s Sherlock to return. Having been recognized with breast most cancers, the episode’s flash-forward revealed that she was efficiently cancer-free, reuniting together with her longtime companion to renew their detective consultancy beneath the supervision of Marcus, now the captain of the precinct. Moreover, Sherlock remained sure that Moriarty had faked her dying, and thus was able to preserve attempting to find her.
Associated
It has been six years since Elementary went off the air. In 2025, nonetheless, it is lastly getting a religious successor now {that a} new present.
Regardless of the door being open for extra, nonetheless, there are some obstacles that an Elementary revival would face in getting off the bottom. The largest one is that CBS at the moment has Watson on the air, which gives one other modern-day tackle its eponymous character, albeit this time with the plot thread that Sherlock is outwardly useless, and its incarnation of the character is continuous along with his personal investigations. Contemplating each Chestnut and Liu’s Watson are technically the identical character, and What We Do within the Shadows‘ Matt Berry can be enjoying Sherlock, it will create a continuity confusion for audiences.
The opposite main hurdle dealing with Elementary‘s potential roadmap again to the display is the potential for an oversaturation of Sherlock Holmes-related content material on display. Along with Watson, Prime Video additionally has the upcoming Younger Sherlock collection from director Man Ritchie and led by Hero Fiennes Tiffin within the titular function, whereas Netflix can also be at the moment growing an Enola Holmes 3. There’s additionally Robert Downey Jr.’s long-gestating Sherlock Holmes 3 and potential Sherlock season 5 for Benedict Cumberbatch that would make audiences lose curiosity within the materials altogether.
Our Take On A Potential Elementary Revival
Liu & Miller Are Higher Off Letting Their Sherlock & Watson Alone
In a time during which Downey Jr.’s films and Cumberbatch’s BBC present had been dominating the marketplace for Sherlock Holmes diversifications, I used to be at all times adamant that Elementary was not solely an underrated one, but additionally arguably one of the best one, because of its deeper deal with character improvement over its mysteries. Whereas I am unable to deny that I do miss seeing Liu and Miller’s incarnations of their basic characters, I do suppose that regardless of the open nature of the finale, there was sufficient decision to depart them be.
